Does security awareness and phishing training actually work?
On its own, less than its sellers suggest. A 2025 study of more than 19,500 employees at UC San Diego Health found no significant link between annual training and how often people clicked simulated phishing links, and training shown right after a click helped only slightly. Training is still worth running, and HIPAA requires it, but it works best as one layer behind email filtering, phishing-resistant multi-factor authentication and endpoint detection that catch what people miss.
What the evidence says
Researchers at UC San Diego ran an eight-month randomized experiment, sending simulated phishing emails to more than 19,500 UC San Diego Health employees. They found no significant relationship between completing the annual training and falling for the emails. The short lesson shown after a click reduced the likelihood of clicking by about 2%, according to the university's summary.
Put these in front of the training
- Email filtering that stops most phishing before it reaches an inbox.
- Phishing-resistant multi-factor authentication, such as security keys or passkeys, so a password typed into a fake page is not enough.
- Endpoint detection, watched around the clock, for the click that gets through.
- A one-click report button, and no blame for reporting a mistake quickly.
When training is required
- HIPAA lists security awareness and training among the Security Rule's administrative safeguards.
- Cyber insurance applications often ask whether staff are trained. Check yours.
- Client security questionnaires usually ask too.
What Zero-Trust Compliance includes
- Avanan inline email security
- Huntress security awareness training and phishing simulations
- DNSFilter Plus and Dropsuite backup
Next steps.
Sources and further reading
- Ho et al., Understanding the Efficacy of Phishing Training in Practice (IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy, 2025) ↗
- UC San Diego: cybersecurity training programs don't prevent employees from falling for phishing scams ↗
- 45 CFR 164.308(a)(5): security awareness and training ↗
- CISA: Implementing Phishing-Resistant MFA (fact sheet) ↗